# Reprint Push Go/No-Go Release Decision Record Variant: RPP-0920 go/no-go release decision record variant 1 Status: support-only decision record Final release: **NO-GO** This record is support documentation only. It does not approve release, does not authorize production apply, does not move release gates, and does not close any production release risk. The current final-release evaluator names 18 remaining blocking risks. Because no production-backed closure proof is present in this slice, every named remaining risk stays open. ## Decision Record ```json { "schemaVersion": 1, "rppId": "RPP-0920", "recordId": "rpp-0920-go-no-go-release-decision-record-v1", "variant": 1, "status": "final-go-no-go-recorded", "supportOnly": true, "productionBacked": false, "releaseEligible": false, "finalReleaseStatus": "NO-GO", "integrationRecommendation": "NO-GO", "decision": { "outcome": "NO-GO", "reason": "Production-backed closure proof is absent for every remaining blocking final-release risk.", "productionClosureProofObserved": false, "riskRegisterComplete": true, "remainingRiskCount": 18, "closedRiskCount": 0, "namedOrClosedRiskCount": 18, "dispositionRule": "Each remaining release risk remains open unless production-backed closure proof closes it." }, "auditedContext": { "checkedAt": "2026-06-01T02:09:00.000Z", "auditedBranch": "session/rpp-920", "auditedHeadBeforeEvidence": "59b234e08b93b816b8ccecb17b02fce8a724e6da", "releaseGateCommand": "node scripts/release/check-release-gates.mjs --scope final-release --now 2026-06-01T02:09:00.000Z", "releaseGateExitCode": 1, "mutationAttempted": false }, "releaseGateSnapshot": { "releaseStatus": "NO-GO", "primaryFailureCode": "REPRINT_PUSH_LIVE_SOURCE_REQUIRED", "primaryFailureBucket": "topology", "statusMarker": "[release-gates-ci:held final=3/21 candidate=3/21 reason=REPRINT_PUSH_LIVE_SOURCE_REQUIRED]", "releaseMovementAllowed": false, "finalGates": "3/21", "candidateGates": "3/21", "totals": { "gates": 21, "passed": 3, "candidate": 0, "missing": 18, "failed": 0, "blocking": 18 } }, "missingProductionEvidenceBuckets": [ { "bucket": "topology", "gateCount": 3, "gateIds": [ "source-url", "local-url", "remote-changed-url" ] }, { "bucket": "auth", "gateCount": 4, "gateIds": [ "auth-source-readback", "production-secret", "application-password-binding", "manage-options-capability" ] }, { "bucket": "identity", "gateCount": 1, "gateIds": [ "same-source-identity" ] }, { "bucket": "route", "gateCount": 3, "gateIds": [ "preflight-route-identity", "dry-run-route-eligibility", "apply-route-pre-mutation" ] }, { "bucket": "recovery", "gateCount": 2, "gateIds": [ "journal-route-read-only", "recovery-inspect-read-only" ] }, { "bucket": "storage", "gateCount": 1, "gateIds": [ "storage-boundary-cas" ] }, { "bucket": "operator-proof", "gateCount": 4, "gateIds": [ "tmux-status-marker", "progress-release-timestamp", "agents-release-gates-row", "verify-release-failure-reason" ] } ], "remainingRisks": [ { "id": "source-url", "rpp": "RPP-0001", "category": "topology", "title": "REPRINT_PUSH_SOURCE_URL gate", "code": "REPRINT_PUSH_LIVE_SOURCE_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "REPRINT_PUSH_SOURCE_URL is required before release gates can run preflight, dry-run, apply, or recovery.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed live source URL evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "local-url", "rpp": "RPP-0002", "category": "topology", "title": "REPRINT_PUSH_LOCAL_URL gate", "code": "REPRINT_PUSH_LOCAL_URL_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "REPRINT_PUSH_LOCAL_URL is required to prove the local edited site boundary.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed local edited site boundary evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "remote-changed-url", "rpp": "RPP-0003", "category": "topology", "title": "REPRINT_PUSH_REMOTE_CHANGED_URL gate", "code": "REPRINT_PUSH_REMOTE_CHANGED_URL_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "REPRINT_PUSH_REMOTE_CHANGED_URL is required to prove stale remote replay fails before mutation.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed remote-changed source boundary evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "auth-source-readback", "rpp": "RPP-0006", "category": "auth", "title": "Auth source command readback drift", "code": "PRODUCTION_AUTH_SESSION_BOUNDARY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Auth source command readback must prove the same live source URL used at issuance and readback.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed auth source command readback proving the same live source URL at issuance and readback." }, { "id": "production-secret", "rpp": "RPP-0007", "category": "auth", "title": "Missing production secret gate", "code": "REPRINT_PUSH_SECRET_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Production credential evidence is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed credential or auth session source command evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "application-password-binding", "rpp": "RPP-0008", "category": "auth", "title": "Application Password credential binding", "code": "APPLICATION_PASSWORD_BINDING_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Application Password credential binding must be proven against the checked source identity.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed Application Password binding evidence against the checked source identity." }, { "id": "manage-options-capability", "rpp": "RPP-0009", "category": "auth", "title": "manage_options capability proof", "code": "MANAGE_OPTIONS_CAPABILITY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "manage_options capability proof is required for the checked production user.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed manage_options capability evidence for the checked production user." }, { "id": "same-source-identity", "rpp": "RPP-0010", "category": "identity", "title": "Same source URL identity proof", "code": "SAME_SOURCE_IDENTITY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Same source URL identity proof is required across preflight, dry-run, apply, journal, and recovery.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed same-source identity evidence across preflight, dry-run, apply, journal, and recovery." }, { "id": "preflight-route-identity", "rpp": "RPP-0011", "category": "route", "title": "Preflight route identity proof", "code": "PREFLIGHT_ROUTE_IDENTITY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Preflight route identity proof is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed preflight route identity evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "dry-run-route-eligibility", "rpp": "RPP-0012", "category": "route", "title": "Dry-run route eligibility proof", "code": "DRY_RUN_ROUTE_ELIGIBILITY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Dry-run route eligibility proof is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed dry-run route eligibility evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "apply-route-pre-mutation", "rpp": "RPP-0013", "category": "route", "title": "Apply route pre-mutation proof", "code": "APPLY_ROUTE_PRE_MUTATION_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Apply route pre-mutation rejection proof is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed apply route pre-mutation rejection evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "journal-route-read-only", "rpp": "RPP-0014", "category": "recovery", "title": "Journal route read-only proof", "code": "JOURNAL_ROUTE_READ_ONLY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Journal route read-only proof is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed journal route read-only evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "recovery-inspect-read-only", "rpp": "RPP-0015", "category": "recovery", "title": "Recovery inspect read-only proof", "code": "RECOVERY_INSPECT_READ_ONLY_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Recovery inspect read-only proof is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed recovery inspect read-only evidence supplied to the final release evaluator." }, { "id": "storage-boundary-cas", "rpp": "RPP-0021", "category": "storage", "title": "Storage-boundary CAS proof", "code": "STORAGE_BOUNDARY_CAS_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "Storage-boundary CAS proof is required for every final target write before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed evidence that every final target write is guarded at the storage boundary, revalidated before mutation, and rejects stale-at-write attempts." }, { "id": "tmux-status-marker", "rpp": "RPP-0017", "category": "operator-proof", "title": "tmux stdout proof status marker", "code": "TMUX_STATUS_MARKER_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "A final bracketed stdout status marker is required for tmux-visible release gate proof.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed final bracketed stdout status marker tied to the checked release run." }, { "id": "progress-release-timestamp", "rpp": "RPP-0018", "category": "operator-proof", "title": "progress.html release timestamp", "code": "PROGRESS_RELEASE_TIMESTAMP_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "A release timestamp tied to current evidence is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed progress release timestamp tied to current final-release evidence." }, { "id": "agents-release-gates-row", "rpp": "RPP-0019", "category": "operator-proof", "title": ".agents/RELEASE_GATES.md status row", "code": "AGENTS_RELEASE_GATES_ROW_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": ".agents/RELEASE_GATES.md status row evidence is required before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed machine-readable release gate status row evidence for the checked run." }, { "id": "verify-release-failure-reason", "rpp": "RPP-0020", "category": "operator-proof", "title": "verify:release nonzero failure reason", "code": "VERIFY_RELEASE_FAILURE_REASON_REQUIRED", "disposition": "open", "releaseBlocker": true, "productionBackedClosureObserved": false, "namedRisk": "verify:release must prove nonzero failures include a named reason before release movement.", "closureRequired": "Production-backed verify:release output proving named failure reason behavior for held releases." } ], "closedRisks": [], "nonRiskPassedEvaluatorChecks": [ { "id": "packaged-fallback", "rpp": "RPP-0004", "status": "passed", "treatment": "Not a remaining risk in the current evaluator; RPP-0920 does not claim a new production risk closure." }, { "id": "remote-alias", "rpp": "RPP-0005", "status": "passed", "treatment": "Not a remaining risk in the current evaluator; RPP-0920 does not claim a new production risk closure." }, { "id": "release-movement-summary", "rpp": "RPP-0016", "status": "passed", "treatment": "Not a remaining risk in the current evaluator; RPP-0920 does not claim a new production risk closure." } ], "evidenceLimits": { "mode": "support-only-risk-register", "rawUrlsIncluded": false, "credentialsIncluded": false, "payloadsStored": false, "releaseGateChanged": false, "releaseGateStatusMovement": "none", "progressRecordChanged": false, "progressPageChanged": false, "completionChecklistChanged": false, "statusFilesChanged": false, "dashboardsStarted": false, "remoteTunnelsUsed": false }, "validation": [ "node --check test/rpp-0920-go-no-go-release-decision-record.test.js", "node --test --test-name-pattern RPP-0920 test/rpp-0920-go-no-go-release-decision-record.test.js", "node scripts/release/artifact-redaction-scan.mjs docs/release/go-no-go-release-decision-record.md docs/evidence/rpp-0920-go-no-go-release-decision-record.md", "git diff --check" ] } ``` ## Remaining Release Risks All remaining risks below are open. None are closed by this support-only record. | Risk | Status | Release blocker | Named risk | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | RPP-0001 source-url | Open | Yes | REPRINT_PUSH_SOURCE_URL is required before release gates can run preflight, dry-run, apply, or recovery. | | RPP-0002 local-url | Open | Yes | REPRINT_PUSH_LOCAL_URL is required to prove the local edited site boundary. | | RPP-0003 remote-changed-url | Open | Yes | REPRINT_PUSH_REMOTE_CHANGED_URL is required to prove stale remote replay fails before mutation. | | RPP-0006 auth-source-readback | Open | Yes | Auth source command readback must prove the same live source URL used at issuance and readback. | | RPP-0007 production-secret | Open | Yes | Production credential evidence is required before release movement. | | RPP-0008 application-password-binding | Open | Yes | Application Password credential binding must be proven against the checked source identity. | | RPP-0009 manage-options-capability | Open | Yes | manage_options capability proof is required for the checked production user. | | RPP-0010 same-source-identity | Open | Yes | Same source URL identity proof is required across preflight, dry-run, apply, journal, and recovery. | | RPP-0011 preflight-route-identity | Open | Yes | Preflight route identity proof is required before release movement. | | RPP-0012 dry-run-route-eligibility | Open | Yes | Dry-run route eligibility proof is required before release movement. | | RPP-0013 apply-route-pre-mutation | Open | Yes | Apply route pre-mutation rejection proof is required before release movement. | | RPP-0014 journal-route-read-only | Open | Yes | Journal route read-only proof is required before release movement. | | RPP-0015 recovery-inspect-read-only | Open | Yes | Recovery inspect read-only proof is required before release movement. | | RPP-0021 storage-boundary-cas | Open | Yes | Storage-boundary CAS proof is required for every final target write before release movement. | | RPP-0017 tmux-status-marker | Open | Yes | A final bracketed stdout status marker is required for tmux-visible release gate proof. | | RPP-0018 progress-release-timestamp | Open | Yes | A release timestamp tied to current evidence is required before release movement. | | RPP-0019 agents-release-gates-row | Open | Yes | .agents/RELEASE_GATES.md status row evidence is required before release movement. | | RPP-0020 verify-release-failure-reason | Open | Yes | verify:release must prove nonzero failures include a named reason before release movement. | Closed risks: none. Production-backed closure proof observed: none. ## Go/No-Go Decision Decision: **NO-GO**. The release remains held at `3/21` final gates and `3/21` candidate gates. The primary blocking failure is `REPRINT_PUSH_LIVE_SOURCE_REQUIRED`. No mutation was attempted by the evaluator, no release-gate status moved, and no checklist, progress log, progress page, dashboard, or status file movement is authorized by this record. Integration recommendation: **NO-GO** for release movement until each open risk above has production-backed proof or the final-release evaluator reports it closed on the checked release path.